Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Marriage - a complicated issue!



 

I am fortunate. I am married to my best friend. My soul mate. My other half. And we firmly believe that God led us to each other early on. Too many ‘coincidences’ allowed us to meet and then to date. Thirty-five years later, we’re still very much in love and still growing together. It hasn’t always been perfect – far from it – but it’s been real. Truly in good times and in bad. Our course book notes that “...true friendship between the spouses is central – if it exists, the relationship can weather many a storm; if it is missing, there is a void that belies the external bonds between them.”* So how do people learn if they are truly friends before marriage? And if they can, will this help stop the flood of marriages that eventually end in divorce? Because the storms in life will come. One of my favorite movies is Fiddler on the Roof. There is a very appropriate song in it – Do you love me? Watch it here on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h_y9F5St4j0 The marriage between Tevye and Golde was a pre-arranged match, but they learned to love each other. Most Americans would frown on having a pre-arranged match - I certainly would have – but the song asks a very important question that should be answered: Do you love me? How would you answer that for yourself??

Sadly, there are some marriages that simply should not continue. My daughter was the victim of abuse and ran from a marriage to protect herself and her baby. That reason for divorce was not mentioned in the Bible, but I’m fairly certain Jesus loves her then and now and understands. Many well-meaning Christians thought she should stay in this abusive relationship at all costs. My biological father walked out on my mother before I was born. The divorce was no problem, but her later marriage to the wonderful man who became my Dad was filled with issues: My mother was banned from receiving Sacraments and she was looked down upon by others in her church community. She was called an adulterer by my high school religion teachers – a word a vehemently denied. Later, the pope gave his blessing to have the first marriage annulled and my mother was free to participate once again in the Mass. And in some odd way, I felt like I suddenly became illegitimate.

Marriage, commitment, friendship, sacrament. And we see that with anything involving people – very complicated indeed!

 *Photo: The Wedding of the Virgin from http://www.catholictradition.org/Galleries/stained-glass31.jpg
Cooke, Bernard and Macy, Gary. Christian Symbol and Ritual: An Introduction. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005. Print.

Does the reality match the sign?

The readings on marriage and holy orders and their development in the Church over the centuries made it clear that Jesus had not organized his new church very carefully. Could he have consciously chosen to leave its future in the hands of his motley crew of followers, trusting that his Spirit would indeed be with them, and bring to their minds all that he had taught them? Did he trust that the Good News would insinuate itself into and transform from inside whatever culture became their home? I was particularly interested in the fact that apparently marriage was not considered a sacrament until Peter Lombard spoke of it in the 12th Century, and even then there was no officially recognized wedding ceremony that had to be observed (C&M 59). Traditional marriage rites were commonly used by Christians, whether of Jewish or Gentile descent. The Jewish rituals were very formal; marriages were arranged by the fathers of the bride and groom. I would think that modifications would have been made little by little over the centuries, particularly after Christians were expelled from the synagogues, but I haven’t yet found information on that. Perhaps common law marriages were the most common form. One indication might be that at the time of Ignatius of Antioch in the 2nd century, he advised Christian men and women to get the approval of the bishop before they married (Johnson 292). Another clear sign would be the copy of the nuptial Mass and Blessing which Pope Hadrian I sent Emperor Charlemagne in the 8th century (J 293-294). A fascinating aspect of the Hadrianum was that all of the many blessings proposed were oriented toward the woman, focusing on her chastity, fidelity, and need of God’s protection. Were these not equally needed by the man? In the 12th century, Peter Lombard insisted that marriage was a sacrament “that nature might be protected and sin repressed,” but also because “it is also a sacred sign … of the union of Christ and the Church” (quoted in J 296-297). The couple getting married were the ministers of the sacrament, not a church official, so if the external form was culturally acceptable, they were validly married. Calvin mocked the idea that marriage was a sacrament, but then blamed the mistake on a misunderstanding of the word used by St. Paul (J 297-298). The official Roman marriage ritual was not set until fifty years after the Council of Trent. In that ritual, apparently only the woman was given a ring, and the purpose of marriage was said to be “the propagation of the human race” (J 299-300); only after Vatican II did both parties give rings to one other. Love is the first stated reason for marriage. Fidelity and the acceptance of children come next (J 306). Cooke and Macy speak of purposes of marriage. Almost everywhere until relatively recently, marriage partners were chosen by the parents of the bride and groom, based on the background and respectability of the family. The motives were various: they wanted grandchildren to carry on the family line; they wanted to improve their social position; they wanted to secure a political advancement. There usually was a dowry or brideprice involved, according to the culture. Sometimes the partners did not even know each other before the marriage ceremony. It was, of course, hoped that they would be compatible, perhaps even love each other, but this was not the primary motive in the choice. In most cultures, a wife was/is considered the property of her husband, and he could have power of life and death over her. Wife-beating was/is common and accepted. If this was a sign of the union of Christ and the Church, maybe that helps to explain the fearsome image of God held by so many Christians! Vatican II and the Holy Spirit still have a long way to go before the reality behind the sign of marriage is understood.

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Why Go to Mass?

In light of our discussion on the Eucharist this week, this article  in America Magazine by Sr. Mary Ann Walsh really brings the content home for us to our contemporary context.  In Why Go to Mass,  Walsh discusses some real challenges to people's participation in regular weekly worship.  What is really interesting to me are the comments, and the spectrum of ways people are processing her brief story.  A worthwhile question for ministry: how would you enter into conversation with this article or with any one of the comments below?

Mosaic panel with the Emperor Justinian in a Eucharistic Procession, San Vitale, Ravenna, mid 6th century 

Posting on Behalf of Judy

Christ makes us an offer

I used to think of the Mass as the celebration that made Jesus present so you could receive him in Communion.  I thought that the important part began with the Offertory.  The penitential rite, the readings, homily, and creed were sort of an introduction; they were important, but one was not late for Mass if one arrived in time for the Offertory.   That is what I learned in grammar school.
My understanding has grown since then.  I understand that the prayers and readings follow the pattern of Jewish rituals, and that the Word of God speaks to us through the scripture readings.  The homily follows early Christian practice, when the person who was able to read the Hebrew scriptures and letters received from community leaders would read and then comment on them (Cooke and Macy 96).  I also learned this week that for many Protestant Churches, the readings and the sermon are considered the most important part of the service, because that is where religious instruction is chiefly given.  That is why they only occasionally celebrate the Lord’s Supper.
Now I understand the Mass as the celebration that makes the Last Supper present and active in the Christian community.  In it, through the ministry of the priest, Christ changes bread and wine into his Body and Blood.  God offers his Son to us to be our food.  If we welcome it with faith and an open heart – like the deer that longs for streams of water (Ps 42:2)  – we enter into communion with Christ, sharing his life, and vice versa. 
Schillebeeckx speaks of Christ’s presence in the host as an offer. 
The presence becomes reciprocal – that is to say, presence in the full and completive human sense – only in the acceptance of this offered presence, and in that way it becomes the presence of Christ in our hearts, which is the very purpose of the eucharist (J 248).
Christ shares with us the desires and longings of his heart, and as our relationship deepens, our greatest joy is to live as Jesus lived, participating in his mission to make his Father known and loved. 


All of my reading and reflection on the Eucharist since I began the LIM program have deepened my joy and love of the Mass, as well as my joy in sharing the love of God each week with the women in the prison - as well as everywhere in my life.